Friday, February 14, 2014

Mechanical vs. Hydraulic Shears

The shear is one of the most fundamental machines in nearly every machine shop, designed specifically to effectively and efficiently cut material, both thick and thin in a quick and timely manner. Like scissors, or any other shearing tool, the metal shear is comprised of two blades; one on the lower end that is attached firmly on the stationary table, and one on the upper end that is attached to the moving ram. This ram can either be driven in several ways, but the two most commonly used are either mechanical or hydraulic.

Hydraulic shears are driven by a motor and pump that has oil pumped into various hydraulic valves and cylinders that ultimately allow the ram to move. The hydraulic system allows for more operator control, as you can adjust the speed and stroke of the machine to cut accordingly, depending on size and thickness of the material. Also, since the blade on hydraulic shears is driven by the two cylinders on each side of the ram, operators are given a bigger advantage for rake adjustment. By increasing the rake angles of the blades, thicker material can be handled and the capacity of the shear can be effectively increased.

Mechanical shears on the other hand are driven by an eccentric, which is triggered by a flywheel clutch combination. This system allows the machine to be more rigid and have a faster ram cycle than the hydraulic machine. However, unlike the hydraulic shears, the mechanical shears offer less operator control and overload protection as they typically cycle all the way through. This type of shear is more advantageous in shops doing higher production and consistently cutting similar parts.


In summation, whether you go with a mechanical or hydraulic shear will ultimately be on preference.  However, if you are a shop looking for high production and speed, it is probably best you look into a mechanical machine. From what we have noticed, a hydraulic ¼” x 10’ shear seems to be the most commonly desired machine – you should be able to find one for around $20 – $25k, whereas a later model mechanical shear might cost you a bit more money. If we could assist in your search, or help answer any questions, please don’t hesitate to call us.